Welcome Avatar!
Here is a sentence you have read a hundred times this year (and should stop caring about): “crypto is down.”
While true, this statement is completely useless and unactionable. Depending on what you’re holding, your book is either down more or less than “crypto.”
The Bitwise 10 Large Cap Crypto Index is down 29% YTD while Bitcoin is down approximately 26%.
This year, a very narrow cohort of assets has run hard while long tail assets have gotten crushed. HYPE is up 134% YTD and Morpho is up 78%. Maker, Tron and Ondo are also in the green. On the other end, Bitcoin is down 26%, ETH 35%, Aave 34%, Solana 42%, XRP 43% and Sui 54%. The return spread between HYPE and SUI is 190 percentage points.
That spread is the size of the prize for getting the one thing right we have preached for the last three years on DeFi Ed: asset selection.
Regime Changes Drive Your Returns
There is a reason index funds exist in equities and why hedge fund analysts can make millions in some environments then end up fired. It comes down to regime changes.
In a broad “beta regime”, most assets are rising. Picking the best token still helps but simply having market exposure is usually enough to make money. In a narrow “selection regime” a small group of winners must carry a large group of losers. Diversification actually stops protecting you because the basket is filled with assets that are diversifying you away from the few things that are working.
The 2020 to 2021 bull market was the clearest beta regime. In 2021, 226 of 280 tracked coins (81%) finished the year positive. Total crypto market cap increased 188%. You could own BTC, an “ETH killer,” a metaverse token, a DeFi governance token or a dog coin and have a decent chance of looking intelligent by year end.
Beta regimes are the time to left curve. The market rewards exposure more than precision (and brain power).
Today is not that market.
The 9% Club
In a sample of 556 coins, only 48 had positive returns through July 2026. In other words, 9% of the investable universe is up and 91% is flat or down. The dataset does have limitations including survivorship bias and minimum liquidity thresholds but those limitations actually make the results look better than they are.
Total crypto market cap fell 12.6% in Q2, ending June around $2.1 trillion. That was the market’s third consecutive negative quarter and left total capitalization 52% below the October 2025 peak. Bitcoin fell 14.2% during the quarter and ETH fell 25.4%. On the flip side, HYPE broke into the top 10 as Hyperliquid continued expanding.
Crypto cycles repeatedly alternate between periods when exposure is enough and periods when survival depends on selection.
In 2017, nearly everything associated with a blockchain could attract speculative capital. Then in 2018 less than 1% of coins ended the year positive. The average return of the top 100 coins was -83%. In 2021, 81% of a basket of coins ended the year positive. In 2022, only 2% ended the year positive and the top 100 fell 76%.
Knowing what regime you’re in and how to participate in each regime is the difference between a good year and being completely wiped out.
When nearly everything goes up your opportunity cost for picking the wrong winner is limited because your 2nd and 20th picks probably also go up. When only 9% of assets are positive every mediocre position you put on sandbags the few winners in your portfolio.
If you had an equal weight portfolio with one asset up 130% and nine assets down 50%, the portfolio is still down 32%. You found a winner and still lost money because you diversified into assets that had no reason to exist.
Herein lies one of the biggest pitfalls in crypto - a basket of familiar names. Familiarity does not mean quality. A token surviving long enough to become recognizable does not mean it will recover its old high, regain users or earn a new valuation. And yet people rush into chasing coins they recognize when an influencer on Crypto Twitter talks about it. Human nature doesn’t change despite multiple cycles of learning the same lessons!
Crypto tokens typically lack the properties that create a valuation floor. There’s no true monetary demand, productive cash flows, creditor claims, redemption value or a buyer of last resort (see: 2022 bankruptcies). The “floor” is simply the price at which another speculator is willing to take the other side. In other words, it’s not a floor at all.
“Waiting for a recovery” is not a strategy when the asset’s users, liquidity and reason for existing are gone. A token down 95% needs a 1,900% gain just to return to its starting point. A token down 99% needs to rise 9,900%. Zoom out on the charts of some of these tokens that are having “bounces” in recent weeks. You might find that a token got your attention after being up 20-30% due to a low liquidity squeeze, but it’s still down 95% in the last 18 months.
This should all feel intuitive. In bearish market conditions everyone checks out of crypto both financially and mentally, which means tokens are available for pennies on the dollar. Picking the right assets can yield a life changing profit if they recover or grow. However, most crypto tokens have no floor from underlying fundamentals or otherwise any reason to exist so when you’re wrong your token will go -99% instead of recovering.
Selection is More Than Finding a Good Protocol
The obvious conclusion is that you need to pick better assets. However, if you’ve been reading us for any meaningful amount of time you would know that “good project” is an inadequate framework.
Let’s take Aave for example. It’s one of the most established lending protocols in DeFi, yet its token is down 34% YTD. A useful and battle tested protocol can still be a weak investment over a particular period because token returns also depend on valuation, broader market dynamics, supply, catalysts and token value capture.
Your selection criteria should have at least the following five components:
Rising relevance: sustained increase in users, volume, deposits, open interest and fees. Qualitative relevance such as narratives and attention also fall into this bucket. Note that metrics should be adjusted or appropriately discounted for token incentives, sybil activity, wash trading, looping and other subsidized or artificial usage.
Token value capture: as the market matures we will see a growing demand for tokens to have clear value capture or a defined path to it. Especially true in selection regimes. We have written dozens of posts on tokenomics over the years and have an entire section dedicated to this in our course - take the time to understand this!
Favorable supply dynamics: Unlocks, emissions, treasury sales and insider ownership often overwhelm genuine demand. A token can be fundamentally improving while its float expands faster than the market can absorb, which often makes it uninvestable for a long period of time.
Valuation: Valuation can be a meme at times in crypto due to the lack of comparability across demand/supply dynamics for tokens. We would maintain that tokenomics are the more important variable. Valuations are most important when a) a token is valued at the extremes (too high or too low) and b) when there exist very clean comparables with well accepted metrics to compare across (e.g. among dexes)
Relative weakness: You often hear people say “relative strength” is an indicator a token’s success. Since tokens are easily manipulated we are skeptical of relative strength in most cases. Instead we’d argue that relative weakness is a much clearer signal (to stay away). Relative strength can be gamed, but there’s typically no point in faking relative weakness.
Note: this framework is not for identifying every future winner. The goal in the current regime is to keep bad assets out of your portfolio.
Concluding Thoughts
Your portfolio isn’t a museum. You don’t just put in every thesis you have ever found interesting. Every position consumes capital and attention. When more than 90% of assets are flat or negative the threshold for inclusion must be kept high.
This is the environment where discipline matters most. Select carefully, size appropriately and remain willing to change your mind when the evidence changes.
When the next regime shift arrives there will be a time to press exposure again.
To go deeper on how we evaluate tokens, paid subscribers can read our ongoing work on tokenomics, valuation, supply dynamics and individual protocols.
Paid subscribers also get access to:
All of our past posts
Weekly Deep Dive Report
A comprehensive bi-weekly DeFi Roundup
Bi-weekly Q&A sessions with our team
Until next time..
Disclaimer: None of this is to be deemed legal or financial advice of any kind. These are opinions from an anonymous group of cartoon animals with Wall Street and Software backgrounds.
We now have a full course on crypto that will get you up to speed (Click Here)
We offer the Prediction Markets module on a standalone basis (Click Here)
Security: Our official views on how to store Crypto correctly (Click Here)
What do you think of something like wlfi or dolo?